Bob Dylan - Modern Times (Columbia)

"Epic", "another masterwork", "his best in decades" ran some of the reviews. It isn't. It's not bad - but we've come to hope for more after 40 years of innovation and turning expectation on its head. And that's my real problem with the album. Once you've started, it's predictable. Rolling Stone magazine said in its review: "This music is relaxed; it has nothing to prove. It is music of accumulated knowledge, it knows every move, anticipates every step before you take it." I would sum that up in one word: tired.
In a series of slow waltzes and blues shuffles, Dylan sounds like the pensioner he is, taking another turn around the tea dance floor. He says the band is the best he has ever worked with. They are tight - but you can anticipate every turn of musical phrase bars ahead and they never defy your expectation. Is this, as some suggest, an homage to tradition, their blues folk roots, or is it, as I fear, just a failure of imagination?
Someday Baby and Workingman's Blues 2 lift their heads and show what might have been and the final track Ain't Talkin' has a trace of the old menace. But for the most part the songs, like his voice, sound frail. I shall return to Desire, Blood on The Tracks and even Time Out of Mind, but not often to his view of Modern Times I fear.